Elihu's Third Speech: Your Cry Has Not Reached God

Log in to take the quiz and save your progress.

1. Observe

   What transactional question does Elihu attribute to Job and find problematic (v. 3)?

   • Whether God exists at all
   • Whether the friends are right
   • The question 'What advantage will it be to you? What profit shall I have, more than if I had sinned?' — treating righteousness as a calculation of personal gain rather than a relationship of worship
   • Whether suffering can be redemptive

2. Observe

   Why, according to Elihu, do the cries of the oppressed often go unanswered (vv. 9-13)?

   • Because they cry out under oppression but no one says 'Where is God my Maker, who gives songs in the night, who teaches us more than the animals of the earth' — the cries are empty cries unconnected to seeking God
   • Because God cannot hear them
   • Because the oppressed deserve it
   • Because there is no God

3. Interpret

   What is the truth — and the limitation — of Elihu's argument that human sin and righteousness do not ultimately affect God (vv. 6-8)?

   • It is fully correct in every application
   • It is entirely wrong about God's character
   • It denies that God ever responds to humans
   • It rightly affirms God's transcendence and self-sufficiency — God is not improved by our virtue or harmed by our sin in his being — but it overstates the case by ignoring that God genuinely responds to human cries throughout Scripture and that the incarnation shows God taking on human concerns as his own in the person of Christ

4. Interpret

   What is the difference between merely crying out in pain and seeking God in the midst of pain (v. 10)?

   • There is no meaningful difference
   • The first directs grief outward at circumstances or in protest, while the second turns the grief upward toward God himself as Maker — naming him, seeking his face, expecting him to give 'songs in the night' even when answers do not come — the target of the cry transforms its character into prayer
   • Only silent suffering pleases God
   • Crying out is always sinful

5. Apply

   To what degree might your expectations of God contain transactional elements, and how do you move from transaction to relationship?

   • Recognizing the transactional element honestly — the expectation that obedience should yield specific outcomes, that prayer should produce results, that loyalty should earn reward — and slowly reframing the relationship around God himself as the gift, learning to delight in him rather than primarily in what he gives, especially through worship in dry seasons
   • Denying that anything in your faith is transactional
   • Treating the transactional element as healthy
   • Withdrawing from prayer altogether

6. Apply

   How can the experience of \"songs in the night\" (v. 10) shape one's practice of worship in dark seasons?

   • Only worshiping when feelings are positive
   • Treating worship as a feeling-driven activity only
   • Avoiding worship in difficult times
   • Cultivating worship as a deliberate discipline that does not wait for circumstances to improve — singing, praying, recalling Scripture, and giving thanks in the dark — and trusting that God himself supplies the very songs the heart could not have produced, which over time becomes one of the deepest evidences of his presence

Your journal

Write your own answers — they save automatically, and only you can see them.

Log in to write and save journal answers.